Dealing with car repairs can be stressful especially when the costs start adding up. What if you end up unable to pay the final bill to a New York auto shop? Do they have the right to keep or sell your car? This guide covers the laws in New York regarding mechanic’s liens and vehicle sales for unpaid service.
Mechanic’s Liens in New York
In New York, auto repair shops have a powerful tool called a “mechanic’s lien” to get paid for vehicle repairs. This lien gives the shop legal possession of the car until you pay the outstanding bill.
Under New York lien law. the repair shop must provide proper written notice to the vehicle owner explaining
- The repair charges owed
- The shop’s intent to retain the car
- The owner’s right to a hearing to contest the lien
If the owner does not pay or dispute the lien after receiving notice, the shop can sell the car at public auction after 30 days. The sale proceeds pay the repair bill, with any leftover given to the prior owner.
Does a Shop Need a Court Order to Sell Your Car?
Repair shops do not need to go to court to sell a vehicle with a mechanic’s lien in New York. The lien procedures spelled out in state law allow them to sell a car to recoup unpaid bills.
However, vehicle owners can fight the lien by requesting a hearing with the Department of Motor Vehicles (DMV) Consumer Complaint Unit. This may temporarily halt the sale while disputed.
When Can a Lien Be Challenged in New York?
There are certain situations where vehicle owners may contest a mechanic’s lien and stop a public sale:
- The shop did not provide proper lien notification as required by law
- The repairs exceeded the initial written estimate without approval
- The work was defective, unnecessary, or overpriced
Vehicle owners typically have 90 days from the repair date to challenge a lien with the DMV. Quick action is essential if you dispute the charges.
What Recourse Exists After Your Car is Sold?
If you were not able to successfully fight the lien in time, and the shop auctioned your vehicle, options become more limited. But a few possibilities remain:
- File a complaint demanding the excess sale funds beyond the repair bill
- Sue the shop for violations of lien procedures
- Claim the shop violated deceptive business practice laws
- Argue the shop engaged in an illegal conversion of property
The success of these options turns on the specific circumstances of each case. Having proper documentation of your interactions with the repair shop is crucial.
Avoiding Vehicle Sale Over Repair Bills
No one wants the headache and financial loss of having their car sold without their consent. Here are some tips to avoid this outcome:
- Review estimates closely and approve any increased costs promptly
- Voice any concerns over repair quality right away
- Pay whatever amount you can, even if partial
- Discuss payment plans or adjustments to avoid passing 30 days
- Respond immediately to any lien notifications
- Contact DMV at the first sign of dispute
Staying engaged with the repair shop, keeping documentation, and acting quickly can help you prevent the seizure and sale of your car over unpaid bills. Know your consumer rights, but also take steps to avoid ever needing to exercise them.
What To Do if You Get a Mechanic’s Lien Notice in New York
Receiving a mechanic’s lien notice can be shocking, but it does not necessarily mean you will lose your car. Here are the important first steps to take:
-
Review the notice details critically. Make sure it follows New York laws and the facts align with your records.
-
Contact the shop immediately. Discuss payment options and negotiate a possible resolution. Get any deals in writing.
-
Pay whatever you can, even a portion of the bill. Partial payment shows good faith.
-
File a complaint with the NY DMV if you dispute the lien validity. Act fast to halt a sale.
-
Seek legal assistance from a consumer lawyer if needed to protect your rights.
With prompt action and documentation, you may be able to defeat an improper lien. But move quickly, as the 30-day clock starts ticking once you receive the lien notice.
Key Takeaways on New York Mechanic’s Liens
-
New York repair shops can retain and sell your car over unpaid bills.
-
They must provide proper lien notice and wait 30 days first.
-
Vehicle owners can contest questionable or excessive liens.
-
Act fast once you receive a lien notice to avoid losing your car.
-
Pay whatever you can and negotiate payment plans if possible.
Knowing the laws and your consumer rights is crucial to handle a mechanic’s lien in New York properly. But avoiding one altogether through clear communications and prompt payments remains ideal.
How do You Pursue a Claim Against the Mechanic for Defective Work?
Challenging a mechanic’s lien is only one potential avenue for a person dealing with defective repairs. If you are injured in an accident caused by shoddy repair work to your vehicle, you could have a civil claim against the mechanic or shop owner.
A claim for defective repairs must meet the same requirements that are involved in any motor vehicle accident. The first step involves proving the mechanic owed you a duty of care. By accepting payment to repair your vehicle, this element is usually not at issue.
Next, you must show they violated that duty of care by carelessly or recklessly failing to adequately repair your vehicle. This can involve evidence that they failed to recognize a necessary fix, used the wrong part, or simply performed shoddy work.
The third element requires you to prove causation. Causation is the link between the mechanic’s negligent work and your losses. You must show your vehicle accident only occurred due to negligent repair work. Finally, you must demonstrate that you suffered losses from the accident. This could be anything from medical bills to lost wages or even the cost of additional vehicle repairs.
What Is a Mechanic’s Lien?
A mechanic’s lien is a type of security interest that attaches to physical property.
When it comes to motor vehicle repairs, a mechanic’s lien remains in place until the vehicle owner pays for the repairs. However, the law on these liens varies from state to state.
Know Your Rights at the Car Repair Shop | NBCLA
FAQ
What can a mechanic do if a customer doesn’t pay?
What is the repair shop Act in NY?
How do I file a complaint against an auto repair shop in NY?
What to do when your mechanic is ripping you off?
Can a mechanic keep my car if I don’t pay?
If you decide not to pay for the services provided by a car repair shop, the shop may have a legal entitlement to keep your car. The shop owner can obtain a mechanic’s lien if they comply with applicable laws requiring estimates. A lien is a legal property claim that has been improved or otherwise serviced.
What happens if I can’t pay my car repair bill?
If you can’t pay your car repair bill in full, you can ask the auto repair shop if they will accept payments toward it instead. Be cautious, as mechanics have the right to legally put a ‘mechanic’s lien’ on your car if you haven’t paid the bill in 30 days.
What happens if a customer doesn’t pay a car Bill?
If the customer settles the bill, they receive their car, and the lien is lifted. If the customer doesn’t pay by a set deadline (determined by the state), the shop will move to acquire and/or sell the vehicle. They may advertise a notice of public auction to sell the car to the highest bidder.
What happens if you don’t pay a mechanic?
Unfortunately, the shop has the legal right to keep your car until the charges are paid for. No matter what your reason is for not settling the bill, you might be facing a mechanic’s lien against your vehicle if you don’t pay the mechanic. Scammers have figured out how to use this to their advantage and steal people’s cars.
What if my mechanic did my car repair illegally?
Depending on your state’s law and what is in your service agreement, you may be able to: Sometimes, shops fail to meet states’ requirements under UDAP laws. Contact your state attorney general’s office if you believe your mechanic handled your car repairs illegally.
Can a mechanic sell a car if it has a lien?
A lien is a legal property claim that has been improved or otherwise serviced. This means the mechanic may keep your car until you pay for all authorized repairs. In some cases, the mechanic can even sell your vehicle. This applies even if your car is a $100,000 luxury vehicle that received an inexpensive oil change.