Finding the right insurance company to protect your home and vehicles is a big decision. You want an insurer that is financially stable, provides good customer service, and offers the coverages you need at a fair price. American Mercury Lloyds Insurance Company is one provider that operates predominantly in Texas and Oklahoma.
In this comprehensive guide, we’ll take an in-depth look at American Mercury Lloyds, including:
- Overview of the company
- Financial strength and ratings
- Products and coverage options
- Customer service reputation
- Costs and discounts offered
- How they compare to top insurers like State Farm and Allstate
By the end, you’ll know whether American Mercury Lloyds is the right insurer for your home and auto insurance needs or if you may need to consider alternatives
Brief Background on American Mercury Lloyds Insurance
American Mercury Lloyds is a regional property and casualty insurance company based in Austin, Texas. They currently provide home, renters condo, and auto insurance policies primarily to customers in Texas and Oklahoma.
Some quick facts about American Mercury Lloyds
- Founded in 1960
- Approximately 250,000 policyholders
- Specialize in property risks common in TX and OK
- Products include home, renters, condo, auto, and flood insurance
- Rated B++ (Good) by industry rater A.M. Best
American Mercury Lloyds operates as a Lloyds plan insurer. This means they are structured as a group of underwriters who share resources and distribute risk.
How Strong is American Mercury Lloyds Financially?
When choosing an insurance provider, you want to partner with a financially stable company that will be there to pay claims. So how does American Mercury Lloyds measure up?
They currently hold a B++ or “Good” Financial Strength Rating from A.M. Best. Here’s what this rating indicates:
- They have sufficient capital to meet obligations in the short term
- But may be more vulnerable to adverse conditions than higher rated competitors
On the positive side, American Mercury Lloyds has:
- Grown policyholder surplus to $85 million
- Maintained healthy liquidity and leverage ratios
- Produced solid profits in recent years
Potential drawbacks include:
- Operating in only two states leaves them exposed to regional risks
- Catastrophe modeling may be unrealistic for tornado/hail risks
- Reliance on reinsurance could lead to volatility
Overall, while American Mercury Lloyds appears to have adequate claims paying resources currently, the B++ rating means you need to be cautious depending on your coverage needs. Those with substantial assets may prefer partnering with an insurer rated A- or higher by A.M. Best.
What Products Does American Mercury Lloyds Offer?
American Mercury Lloyds provides a range of basic personal lines insurance products targeted at individuals and families in Texas and Oklahoma:
Home Insurance – Standard HO-3 home insurance as well as older HO-A policies. Coverage options exist for dwellings, other structures, personal property, and loss of use.
Renters Insurance – Policies cover personal belongings against named perils like theft, fire, or water damage. Liability protection is also included.
Condo Insurance – Similar to homeowners but tailored for owner-occupied condos. Loss assessment coverage is sometimes excluded.
Auto Insurance – Minimum state required liability limits as well as higher optional bodily injury and property damage limits. Collision and comprehensive is available.
Flood Insurance – Offered through a partnership with Wright National Flood Insurance.
Unlike large national carriers, American Mercury Lloyds does not currently provide umbrella insurance, scheduled personal property coverage, identity theft protection or mechanical breakdown insurance. Their offerings are focused on basic property and auto policies.
What Do Customers Say About American Mercury Lloyds?
Based on online reviews and complaint data, American Mercury Lloyds earns mixed feedback:
Pros:
- Competitive rates and discounts available
- Simple quoting and policy purchase process
- Responsive claims servicing for minor losses
Cons:
- Major claims often involve delays, re-inspections, and lowball settlement offers
- Limited payment and policy management options compared to big insurers
- Difficulty bundling home and auto policies for multi-policy discounts
Many negative reviews cite unsatisfactory claims handling after major disasters like hailstorms or floods. But customers with basic policies tend to be happier with pricing and servicing.
How Much Does American Mercury Lloyds Insurance Cost?
As a smaller regional company, American Mercury Lloyds can offer lower rates thanks to reduced overhead expenses. Average annual premiums are:
- Auto insurance – $1,150 per vehicle
- Home insurance – $980 for $200,000 dwelling
- Renters insurance – $168 for $30,000 in belongings
Discounts that may help you save include:
- Multi-policy discount for home & auto
- Good payer discount for no late payments
- Paperless discount for electronic documents
- Companion policy discount for a second home or auto policy
Of course, your actual quotes will vary based on your age, driving history, claims record and other factors. Comparing rates from American Mercury Lloyds and competitors helps ensure you get the best deal.
How Does American Mercury Lloyds Compare to Top Insurers?
Measured against leading Texas/Oklahoma home and auto insurers, here is how American Mercury Lloyds generally stacks up:
| Insurer | A.M. Best Rating | Customer Service | Rates |
|---|---|---|---|
| American Mercury Lloyds | B++ | Mixed Reviews | Low |
| State Farm | A++ | Excellent | Low |
| Allstate | A+ | Good | Average |
| Farmers | A | Good | Average |
| USAA | A++ | Excellent | Low |
In terms of financial stability and claims-paying ability, American Mercury Lloyds falls short of competitors like State Farm and USAA. But they can provide cheaper basic policies to qualified customers willing to take on a little more risk.
Is American Mercury Lloyds the Right Insurer for You?
American Mercury Lloyds makes sense for some homeowners and drivers, but not for everyone. Consider American Mercury Lloyds if:
- You want basic home or auto coverage at the lowest cost
- You have an older home without expensive upgrades
- Your vehicle is older or you just need minimum liability
- Top-tier financial strength is not your top priority
For those with more complex risks or who want robust coverages and claims service, American Mercury Lloyds may not be the best choice compared to national brands.
Carefully weigh their pros and cons against your specific insurance priorities. An independent broker can provide additional guidance to match you with the right high-value insurer.
The Bottom Line: Approach with Caution
American Mercury Lloyds offers affordable rates for basic home and auto insurance needs. However, their lack of financial strength compared to competitors gives reason for caution when relying on them to protect your property and assets.
We advise comparing quotes from American Mercury Lloyds along with higher rated national and regional insurers before making a decision. This ensures you secure the optimal blend of coverage, service, and savings in partnership with a stable insurer.
We’ve detected unusual activity from your computer network
To continue, please click the box below to let us know youre not a robot.