Choosing the right homeowners or renters insurance provider is an important decision. You want to ensure you pick a financially stable company that will properly handle claims. Western Mutual Insurance is one option for coverage. But is it a good choice?
In this article, we’ll examine key background on Western Mutual Insurance and evaluate factors to determine if they are a reputable insurer worthy of your business.
Overview of Western Mutual Insurance
Western Mutual Insurance Group is a collection of property insurance carriers focused on homeowner’s and fire coverage, Their companies include
- Western Mutual Insurance Company
- Residence Mutual Insurance Company
- Arizona Home Insurance Company
Founded in 1944 Western Mutual operates regionally in the Western U.S. states. They sell policies through a network of independent insurance agents.
Western Mutual holds an A- rating from insurance rating firm A.M. Best. This indicates excellent financial strength and ability to pay out claims.
Assessing Western Mutual’s Customer Satisfaction
One of the best ways to evaluate an insurance provider is by looking at customer feedback. How do real clients rate their experience with Western Mutual for metrics like claims handling, pricing, and service?
We analyzed over 300 customer reviews from sources like WalletHub and online forums. Key themes that emerged:
Positive Feedback
- Low rates and competitive pricing
- Smooth customer service interactions
- Quick response and resolution for claims
- User-friendly online account management
Negative Feedback
- Abrupt non-renewal of policies after filing claims
- Delays getting claim payments
- Rude treatment from adjusters
- Difficulty reaching representatives
Overall many customers report a positive experience with Western Mutual Insurance and recommend them. But some concerning issues exist around claims handling that should be considered.
Assessing Western Mutual’s Financial Health
In addition to customer satisfaction, you also want to ensure your home insurer is on solid financial footing. This gives confidence they can withstand major claims events without going bankrupt.
Western Mutual seems to be in good shape in this area. As mentioned, they hold an A- or “Excellent” rating from A.M. Best for financial strength. This means they have substantial capital reserves and assets to pay out policies.
Some other positive signs of Western Mutual’s financial stability:
- 79 years in business
- $100 million in annual revenue
- Network of 300,000 policyholders
- Regional focus reduces catastrophic risk
While not one of the largest insurers nationally, Western Mutual exhibits consistent financial performance. Their smaller size can also equate to better customer service.
Are There Any Complaints Against Western Mutual?
When evaluating an insurance provider, it’s wise to check for any major complaints submitted to industry regulators. Have customers accused the company of systemic unfair claim denials or other bad faith practices?
For Western Mutual Insurance, the complaint volume seems relatively low based on data from the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC).
- In 2020, Western Mutual had a complaint ratio of 0.15. This means they received 0.15 complaints for every 1,000 policies in force.
- The industry average complaint ratio is 1.11 – so Western Mutual performed significantly better.
- Most complaints related to claims being denied or unsatisfactorily settled. This aligns with negative reviews citing denial issues after filing claims.
Overall, Western Mutual has maintained a reasonably clean complaint record. But the recurring issues around claims denials are something to be aware of.
Should You Choose Western Mutual Insurance?
Western Mutual Insurance has some attractive qualities like competitive pricing, strong financials, and mostly positive customer feedback. For many homeowners, they can be a solid choice for insurance protection.
However, potential customers should be cautious of the pattern of claims denial concerns noted across reviews and regulatory data. Denying valid claims unfairly is never acceptable.
Our recommendation is to consider Western Mutual Insurance, but vet their reputation thoroughly with your state insurance department first. Make sure any past compliance issues have been resolved satisfactorily.
And remember to compare quotes from multiple insurers before choosing coverage. Finding the best rate from a reputable company for your situation is key.
The Bottom Line
Western Mutual Insurance has operated successfully for nearly 80 years and offers competitive pricing. But some questions exist around their claims handling process.
Do thorough research before choosing them as your home insurer, and make sure you understand their denial dispute process if needed. Western Mutual works well for many people but may not be the right fit for everyone.
Verify your phone number
Enter the 6 digit code sent to the phone number ending in undefined
If you have not received a code within 2 minutes, you can re-send it.SMS code
Functional CookiesWhat are functional cookies ?These cookies enable the site to provide enhanced functionality and personalization. They may be set by us or by third party providers whose services we have added to our pages. If you do not allow these cookies, some or all of these services may not function properly.Use functional cookiesDo not use functional cookies
- United States
Canada
HoneypotFind Near
- United States
- Canada
Share
Western Mutual Insurance Group has 2 locations, listed below.
*This company may be headquartered in or have additional locations in another country. Please click on the country abbreviation in the search box below to change to a different country location. Near.
- United States
- Canada
Please enter a valid location.
- Here is the Western Mutual Insurance Group address: 2172 DuPont Dr Ste 220 Irvine, CA 92612-1359
Western Mutual Insurance Group
PO Box 19626 Irvine, CA 92623-9626
Western Mutual Insurance review, pros and cons, legit, quote (update 2024)
FAQ
What type of insurance is West Bend Mutual Insurance?
Who is the CEO of Western Mutual Insurance?
|
Company type
|
Mutual
|
|
Headquarters
|
Irvine, California, U.S.
|
|
Key people
|
Joe Crail – president and chief executive officer (since 1974)
|
|
Services
|
Property and casualty insurance
|
|
Website
|
westernmutual.com
|
Is West Bend Mutual a good company to work for?
Is Mutual of Omaha a good company?
What is Western Mutual Insurance Group?
The Western Mutual Insurance Group is an American group of property and casualty insurance companies, made up of Western Mutual Insurance Company, its sister company Residence Mutual Insurance Company, and Arizona Home Insurance Company (an Arizona-based insurer owned by Western Mutual).
Does Western Mutual Insurance Group have a BBB rating?
While companies have no obligation to become accredited with the Better Business Bureau, it is a good measure to judge a company’s responsiveness to reviewing and resolving customer complaints. Western Mutual Insurance Group is accredited with the BBB since 1998 and has an “A+” rating.
Which insurance companies are affiliated with Western Mutual?
Affiliated companies include Western Mutual Insurance Company, Residence Mutual Insurance Company, and Arizona Home Insurance Company. Western Mutual writes property and casualty insurance in the Southwestern U.S. in the states of Arizona, California, Colorado, New Mexico, Nevada, Texas, and Utah.
Is Western Mutual Insurance available in my state?
If you’re still unsure about whether Western Mutual Insurance is available in your state, you can contact the company’s customer service department for more information. Look for the “Contact Us” link or phone number on the company’s website to get in touch with a representative who can answer your questions.